When the Draws Stop: Litigation Risk in a Texas Construction Loan Funding Dispute

Picture a mid-size multifamily project in North Texas, eighteen months into construction. The developer submits its next draw. The lender’s inspector confirms the work is in place, but the lender’s budget review shows the undisbursed loan proceeds will not cover the cost to complete. The lender declares the loan out of balance, demands an equity rebalancing deposit, and refuses to fund. Within weeks, the site goes quiet. The general contractor issues a stop-work notice, subcontractors begin filing lien affidavits, and the developer calls a litigator about suing the bank.

The litigation that follows this fact pattern turns on a few predictable issues. Owners, developers, general contractors, and subcontractors who understand those issues before the draws stop are far better positioned to protect the project, their cash flow, and their claims.

The loan agreement decides the case

Texas courts read a construction loan agreement as a commitment to advance funds on stated terms and conditions, and they enforce those conditions as written. An owner or developer must meet every condition before it can demand an advance. In one dispute, a lender demanded a deposit to cover cost overruns under a clause allowing that demand “before or after an Event of Default,” and the borrowers admitted they could not make it. The lender was not obligated to fund. For a developer, rebalancing clauses are not boilerplate; they are a funding risk that belongs in the project budget and demands contingency planning.

Texas courts enforce lender-friendly drafting. Where conditions existed solely for the lender’s benefit and were waivable in its sole discretion, a Texas court found only one lender duty: to lend up to the note amount once the borrower satisfied the conditions.

Owners, however, still have recourse. Where a borrower had satisfied the conditions to an advance and the lender declined to fund for a reason unrelated to the borrower’s performance, the court found breach. In each of these cases, the text of the draw conditions and the record of whether the borrower met them usually decide the outcome.

Don’t count on “good faith”

Owners and developers often want to plead bad faith, but Texas law generally imposes no duty of good faith and fair dealing in the performance of contracts. The Texas Supreme Court has held that a duty of good faith arises only in special relationships marked by shared trust or an imbalance in bargaining power, and that the mortgagor-mortgagee relationship ordinarily does not qualify. Where courts have found a special lender-borrower relationship, they have pointed to extra facts, such as excessive lender control over the borrower’s business. For most projects, the owner’s case rises or falls on the express language of the contract—not anyone’s good or bad faith.

Course of dealing offers no protection

Developers often argue that a lender that funded earlier draws despite paperwork gaps cannot later insist on strict compliance. But nonwaiver clauses undermine that argument. The Texas Supreme Court has held that nonwaiver provisions are generally binding. Conduct that a party expressly disclaims in a nonwaiver clause cannot, by itself, waive the provision; waiver requires conduct that is unequivocally inconsistent with claiming the right. In the construction loan context, another court likewise held that a lender’s advancing funds without requiring performance of the conditions did not waive them. A lender that bent once has not promised to bend again.

The ripple effect reaches the whole project

A funding dispute rarely stays between two parties. A contractor that goes unpaid may, on proper notice, stop work without liability to the owner or the bank. An interim lender owes no trustee-like duty to unpaid suppliers, even after notice of their lien claims. For general contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers, that means the lender usually will not be the source of payment; their protection lies in their contract, proper notices, and timely lien filings. For owners, the liens and delay costs land on the project.

Three things to do differently

1. Negotiate the draw conditions up front. Push for objective funding standards, a defined out-of-balance calculation, a reasonableness limit on lender discretion, and written notice with a cure period before the lender can refuse a draw. Texas courts disfavor conditions precedent, but they will enforce a notice-and-cure provision as a condition to exercising remedies when the language is conditional, such as requiring notice-and-cure “prior to” refusing to fund or funding “unless” certain conditions are met. Watch for the opposite: language making every funding condition “solely for the benefit of Lender” and waivable in its sole discretion has defeated borrower and lien-claimant claims. Before signing, contractors should also ask how the project is financed and what happens to payment if the draws stop.

2. Build a contemporaneous record. Keep every draw package, inspector report, budget reconciliation, pay application, and lender communication, and document the reason the lender gives for any refusal. Owners have won where the record showed the lender’s stated reason had nothing to do with them, and owners have lost where they never protested before suing and admitted they could not make a required deposit.

3. Follow notice, cure, and reservation-of-rights provisions to the letter. Send notices in the form and manner the loan documents require. When accepting a partial advance or a lender accommodation, reserve your rights in writing. Assume the nonwaiver clause will be enforced, and act accordingly.

When a lender stops funding, the outcome is often set long before anyone sues—in how the draw conditions were drafted and in the paper trail the owner, the contractor, and the lender each built. If you are an owner, developer, general contractor, or subcontractor negotiating a construction loan agreement and need help navigating these provisions, call us.

This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.


Enjoyed this article? Explore the Solid Foundations blog for more practical insights on construction law, industry trends, and project developments.

 

→